Sharp as a Marble
HomeAboutContactSyndicationLogin
 

Jeanne Assam is a hero. There is nothing I can laud upon this woman that makes what she did any greater of a feat. But I don't want to focus on her right now, I want to focus on this (from the Smallest Minority)

If what I heard on the radio this afternoon is correct, there were three armed security people at the church in Colorado Springs. Only one willingly engaged the shooter, calmly walking towards him, firing the entire time. Jeanne Assam fired approximately twelve rounds, and took down someone armed with rifle, shotgun, and pistol and who was reportedly wearing body armor.

...

It's not enough just to have a gun, the defender must be willing and able to use it

The two other guards are going to suffer greatly for years to come. I do not envy their position. During a crisis, they folded their hand and froze. I cast not blame or derision for I cannot honestly say what I will do when my time comes, but forever they will recognize that when their time came, they failed. Luckily for everyone else, Ms. Assam did not.

However, these two put the lie to the concept that a gun in your hand makes you a killer. While reading Lt.Col.  Dave Grossman's excellent book, "On Combat" I learned that during WWII, only something around 20% of soldiers would fire upon the enemy, even if the enemy was actively engaging them.

The part of of our brain that prevents us from murdering our own species is wired that way, through divine intervention or evolution, to keep us from committing what amounts to collective suicide. It doesn't mean it's impossible, but that we're genetically "guided" to have an aversion to killing our own.

As these two guards show, just having a gun in your hand isn't all that is needed to overcome that aversion. Had the guards have had assault rifles as well, it still wouldn't have changed their ability to kill another human being. That ability either comes through training, a psychological disorder, a response to a fight or flight situation, or through the diffusion of responsibility (i.e. someone telling you it's ok and you assuming they have the authority to make that decision or a crew-served weapon where you're not individually responsible) not from a weapon in your hand, not matter how powerful.

Make no mistake about it, we are training our children to overcome their aversion to killing. Violent movies and video games do have an impact of how their minds think. However, that is not the point of this post. The point I am trying to make is that no matter what the anti-rights bigots want you to think, the number of guns has nothing to do with the murder rate. People who have the ability to kill do so because of their training - be it learned through military, police, or private training to the thug culture that desensitizes criminals to the results of their actions.

It's time the Brady Campaign and their ilk stopped blaming the tools and started blaming those who enable the criminals to do what they do and then holding the criminals responsible for their actions. But to do so would undermine their funding and require that they actually do something.

rolled out on Tuesday, December 11, 2007 11:35 AM
Comments
# re: Gun myths - a gun in your hand makes you a killer - Weer'd Beard

Rolled Out On: 12/11/2007 2:57 PM

Great post, Robb, I hadn't thought of it that way.

Of course the Antis don't put it this way, a gun in the hands of a criminal makes them a viscious killer, but a gun in the hands of a lawful person makes them a blubbering moron unable to do anything but allow the criminal to take their gun and shoot them with it.

At least that's what I infer from the scripture of the Church of Hoplophobia

# re: Gun myths - a gun in your hand makes you a killer - straightarrow

Rolled Out On: 12/11/2007 3:14 PM

From the account I read, I will say two things for the guards who could not bring themselves to fire. They stood their ground and one tried to get Mr. Bourbonnais to shield behind him. Not the act of cowards, for either of them.

However, as you said, they failed their primary mission when called upon. Ms. Assam did not.

I wiould not want these men to have by back, but I can't rightfully say they are cowards. Just not tough enough to do the hard thing when it is necessary. Tough is mental and moral, and maybe a little physical, but only a little. Ms. Assam is tough, where it counts, on the inside.

# re: Gun myths - a gun in your hand makes you a killer - PN NJ

Rolled Out On: 12/11/2007 3:26 PM

More information on Grossman's work can be found at the following website:

http://www.killology.com/index.htm

Some of the articles are pretty interesting.

# re: Gun myths - a gun in your hand makes you a killer - Jeff

Rolled Out On: 12/11/2007 9:22 PM

Excellent post.

Arming our citizens won't increase crime but will actually lower it.

Comments have been closed on this topic.
 
TipJar
2A Blogger Bash
Other bloggers with guns.

News

Recently upgraded to Subtext 2.0.

Article Categories


General

Archives


September, 2008 (37)
August, 2008 (93)
July, 2008 (93)
June, 2008 (77)
May, 2008 (79)
April, 2008 (53)
March, 2008 (46)
February, 2008 (46)
January, 2008 (63)
December, 2007 (69)
November, 2007 (63)
October, 2007 (83)
September, 2007 (73)
August, 2007 (84)
July, 2007 (59)
June, 2007 (63)
May, 2007 (35)
April, 2007 (30)
March, 2007 (37)
February, 2007 (32)
January, 2007 (38)
December, 2006 (14)
November, 2006 (28)
October, 2006 (25)
September, 2006 (24)
August, 2006 (28)
July, 2006 (27)
June, 2006 (28)
May, 2006 (14)
April, 2006 (17)
March, 2006 (35)
February, 2006 (33)
January, 2006 (26)
December, 2005 (15)
November, 2005 (22)
October, 2005 (35)
September, 2005 (37)
August, 2005 (50)
July, 2005 (34)
June, 2005 (55)
May, 2005 (53)
April, 2005 (56)
March, 2005 (57)
February, 2005 (77)
January, 2005 (72)
December, 2004 (79)
November, 2004 (76)
October, 2004 (59)
September, 2004 (74)
August, 2004 (69)
July, 2004 (75)
June, 2004 (56)
May, 2004 (28)

Post Categories


Humor (rss)
Views (rss)
Catblogging (rss)
News (rss)
Politics (rss)
Geekdom (rss)
Recipes (rss)
Blogging (rss)
Wingnuts and Moonbats (rss)
War on Terror (rss)
Photography (rss)
Brewsky (rss)
Guns. Lots of Guns. (rss)
Daughter Blogging (rss)
TMI (rss)
Anxiety & Panic Attacks (rss)
Gun Myths (rss)
Reloading (rss)
Range Time (rss)
Anti-Rights Idiocy (rss)
Firearm Safety (rss)
A Cancer Story (rss)
Second Amendment Blog Bash (rss)
Gun Rights (rss)
Gun-Free Zones (rss)
Self Defense (rss)
The Line Is Here (rss)
Getting old sucks (rss)
NRA (rss)
2A Blog Bash (rss)
Out of sight, out of mind (rss)
Video Podcasts (rss)
Para Blackwater Training (rss)

Image Galleries


Beyond the Pale brewing session

::Other Digs


The Line Is Here

::Sharpest Marbles


Eject! Eject! Eject!
Instapundit
Iraq the Model
Protein Wisdom
QandO
Sharp as a Marble
Vodka Pundit
WILLisms
Witting Shire
Wizbang

:Second Amendment


A Keyboard and a .45
Alphecca
Anthroblogogy
Armed and Safe
Call Me Ahab
Carnaby Fudge
Days of our Trailers
Double Tapper
Dustin's Gun Blog
Fighting for Liberty
Great Blue Whale
Gun Owners Against Violence
Gun Pundit
Guntards
Justin Buist
Mike-istan
Musings of the Geek with a 45
Oleg Volk
Papa Delta Bravo
Pro-Gun Progressive
Random Nuclear Strikes
Ride Fast and Shoot Straight
Roberta X
Say Uncle
Sear and Hammer
Snowflakes in Hell
The Anarchangel
The Armed Schoolteacher
The Bitch Girls
The Breda Fallacy
The Countertop Chronicles
The Law Dog Files
The Liberty Sphere
The Mad Rocket Scientist
The Madman Raves
The Other Side of Kim
The Sentinel
The Smallest Minority
The View From North Central Idaho
The War on Guns
View from the porch
West, By God
Xavier thoughts

Blogroll


Guide to Midwestern Culture
Basil's Blog
Captain's Quarters
Coalition of the Swilling
Cold Fury
Cranky Neocon
Daily Pundit
dorkafork
File It Under
Florida Cracker
Garfield Ridge
INDC Journal
Is Full Of Crap
Medium at Large
Notes from the trenches
One Ping Only
Sean Gleeson
Sekimori
Sissy Willis
Six Meat Buffet
Speed of thought
Squeaky Wheel Seeks Grease
The Belmont Club
The Munchkin Wrangler
The Spoons Experience
The Unforgiving Minute
Tim Worstall
UNSpace
Vern's Blog

Extended Blogroll


21st Century Paladin
Bill Peschel
Cowboy Blob
Craziness
Flight Pundit
Hubs and Spokes
In the Right
PEER Review
TechnoChitlins
The Tygrrrr Express

Funny, as in Ha-ha


Ace of Spades HQ
Cox & Forkum
IMAO
ScrappleFace
The Superficial
Topic Drift
Wuzzadem

Good Reads


Drink This
Evil White Guy
Leaning to the Right
Ramble Strip
Save the Soldiers
SondraK
The Resplendent Mango
Triticale
You Big Mouth You

Tampa Area Blogs


Tampa Film Fan

My Technorati Conversations

Hang in there Mom

Cool Post-it Note Icon